Editing Eurovision Wiki:Dispute resolution noticeboard (section)

==== Summary of dispute by Generalrelative ====
<div style="font-size:smaller">Please keep it brief - less than 2000 characters if possible, it helps us help you quicker.</div>
I'm not sure I have much to add to what GorillaWarfare has stated above, other than to concur, and to state that EasternShah's statement below is misleading on a couple of points. 

1) {{tq|Originally...}} Before this revert, GW and I had already made it clear on the talk page that ''if'' this material is to be included it needs to be rephrased to clearly indicate that Platner had nothing to do with the human rights abuses at Abu Ghraib ''and'' a minimal argument for relevance / due weight needs to be made. Despite numerous requests, ES has been unable to provide such an argument. While this conversation was ongoing, ES proceeded to [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Graham_Platner&diff=1344034836&oldid=1344028972 edit war a long string of provocative comments back into the BLP lead], including the Abu Ghraib reference. It was only then that I reverted the entirety of the additions with the edit summary {{tq|Rolling back contested material. Please refer to WP:BLPRESTORE.}} 

2) The argument that {{tq|Platner has not received that much publicity}} is demonstrably and wildly false. GW has [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk%3AGraham_Platner&diff=1344039774&oldid=1344038713 already pointed ES to the article's <u>78</u> sources.] The fact remains that very few of these sources even mention that Platner was once present at Abu Ghraib, so it seems undue for us to do so.

[[User:Generalrelative|Generalrelative]] ([[User talk:Generalrelative|talk]]) 05:47, 19 March 2026 (UTC)